BrianHoltz for Congress - marketliberal.org
Politics
Platform
Comparison
Principles
The Environment
Hidden Agenda
Mortgaged Future
Hall of Shame
You're Wrong
Pamphlet
Announcement
Speech
FAQs
Bio
Site Map

Questions For Rep. Eshoo

  1. Enumerated Powers. You took an oath to uphold the U.S. Constitution, which enumerates the powers of Congress in Article I Sec 8.  Can you indicate the language in Art I Sec 8 that you think authorizes federal entitlement programs like
  2. Limits of Art I Sec 8. Can you give an example of an entitlement or regulation that you think Art I Sec 8 denies Congress the authority to enact?  (Examples: nationalized auto insurance, or mandatory low-flow shower nozzles.)  Do you agree with the Supreme Court (Wickard v. Filburn, 1942) that it is interstate commerce when a farmer grows wheat for consumption on his own farm?
  3. Federalism. You voted for Clinton's federal financing of 100,000 new police officers. Why should my tax dollars make a 6000-mile round-trip to the Treasury building in Washington D.C. just to hire police in my hometown?  Is there any function of local or state government that you think should be off-limits for centralized nationwide funding?  Libraries? Streets?
  4. Limits to Redistribution. How would you recognize a marginal tax rate or a mandatory minimum wage that was too high?  What in your opinion is wrong with a 90% marginal tax rate, or a $20/hr minimum wage?
  5. Explicit Redistribution. Many recipients of Social Security and other federal entitlements are getting back more than what they ever paid in (including inflation and interest). Would you support that Treasury checks to such recipients be printed in a special color, or do you admit that you seek political benefit by allowing people to falsely believe they paid for the benefits you give them?
  6. Markets vs. Regulations. Do you support or oppose the trend in America toward market-based solutions to public policy problems, such as funded parental school choice instead of monopoly public schools, carbon taxes instead of manufacturer mileage rules, and emissions license trading instead of smokestack regulations?