My platform is similar (but
not identical) to the Cato Institute's
600-page
Handbook
for Congress, which is available as a single
3Mb
PDF file.
I have
five major disagreements with
the
Libertarian
Party Platfrom.
1. Principles
1.1. Subjects of Ethics
A being is any entity possessing life,
sentience, or intelligent volition, and are the only entities that have
rights. There are two classes of beings: persons and organisms. A person
is any intelligent being with significant volitional control over how
it affects other beings.
- All persons have the right to life and
liberty.
- All beings have the right not to suffer
torture or extinction.
Thus persons are obligated to minimize the
incidence of
- deaths of persons;
- extinctions of species;
- aggression; and
- torture.
1.2. Objects of Ethics
Property is anything that an agency has
the exclusive right to possess, use, and assign.
- Property can be anything that is not a
person and that can be created or controlled by a person.
- A person has a right to access any unowned
resource to which they have been exercising continuing access.
- A person owns any unowned unaccessed thing
over which he exerts original control.
- A person owns anything he creates from his
property and resources rights.
- A person owns any property, property right,
or resource right consensually assigned by its rightful owner.
- Each property, property right, and resource
right of a person, upon his death, either goes to a chosen assignee or
reverts to being unowned.
A resource is any physical or logical
supply or space which exists without intelligent sustenance and is easy
to use in part but hard to control as a whole, such as air, land,
water, pollution sinks, sunlight, wind, views, fish, game, minerals,
meteorites, space, orbits, bandwidth, public namespaces, etc. Polluting
or monopolizing a resource is aggression against the persons who have
been exercising continuing access to it. A possessable resource
is one, such as land or sunlight, of which a part may be controlled
such that any outsider's use of it is easily detectable by the
controller. Even privatized property interests in unpossessable
resources are subject to the tragedy of the commons, because the owner
cannot readily identify who is violating his interest.
1.3. Ethical Relations
Persons have no right to inflict negative
externalities impacting property and resource rights, and no right to
demand compensation for positive externalities.
Cooperation is the interaction among
persons for mutual benefit. Cooperation is usually positive-sum even
for direct and reversible exchanges, because the exchanging persons
have differing needs or values. The right of association is the
right of persons, except in cases of anti-competitive monopoly, to
cooperate or decline to cooperate with whom they choose. Cooperation
can take many forms. A contract is an explicit understanding
among consenting agents to exchange with or affect each other in a
specified way.
Aggression is the violation by a person
of another person's rights, and consists only of: personal injury,
damage to property, infringement of resource rights, coercion, fraud,
anti-competitive monopoly, or inducement or deceptive incitement of
third parties to any of these. Coercion is compulsion of one
person by another through force or threat of aggression. Fraud
is any attempt to profit by deceiving a person into making a
choice intended to cause him economic harm relative to what would have
been his undeceived choice. Anti-competitive monopoly is the
intentional control or denial of a person's participation in an
industry by the coordinated action of the person(s) controlling that
industry.
Competition is the contrary efforts of
persons to win the consent of some other person(s) to associate in some
way. The infliction of opportunity costs through non-monopolistic
competition does not by itself constitute aggression. Expression is
only aggression if it involves deception that intentionally or
negligently causes actual harm or serious risk thereof, for example by
yelling "fire!" in a crowded (but not burning) theater. Non-deceptive
incitement to aggression is not itself aggression.
Justice is the minimization, reversal
and punishment of aggression. Injustice is unminimized,
unreversed, or unpunished aggression. The minimization of coercion can
itself justify a minimal amount of coercion. Coercion should be
reversed by payment of damages or, if possible, reparation of the
original property or access rights to the coerced persons. Serious
coercion should be punished by loss of freedom, personal interaction,
and even life.
Liberty is volition in the absence of
aggression. Thus justice can also be defined as the most liberty for
the most persons. Freedom is significant volition: the power of
making significant decisions about an agent's own actions. The freedoms
of two persons can be in complete conflict, but their liberties by
definition cannot.
1.4. Purpose of the State
A state is an organization of persons
that has control and sovereignty over a particular region and the
persons in it. To meet their obligation to minimize death,
extinction, aggression, and torture, the persons in a region join
together in a social contract to create or authorize the state. The
purpose of the state is to
- Effect justice (the minimization, reversal,
and punishment of aggression);
- Provide aid and sustenance to persons in
mortal danger;
- Protect species in danger of extinction;
- Prevent torture;
- Regulate natural monopolies; and
- Provide pure public goods.
1.5. Duties of the State
The specific duties of the state are therefore to
- Minimize, reverse, and punish foreign
aggression
- Deter and defend against foreign attack
- Regulate international trade
- Manage annexations and secessions
- Minimize, reverse, and punish domestic
aggression
- Minimize, reverse, and punish coercion
- Prevent force and fraud
- Protect property
- Enforce contracts
- Protect resource rights
- Protect ongoing access to
unowned resources
- Collect rent for use (e.g.
pollution) of unpossessable resources
- Regulate bankruptcy
- Regulate incorporation
- Minimize, reverse, and punish
anti-competitive monopolies
- Regulate natural monopolies
- Prevent anti-competitive artificial
monopolies
- Provide aid and sustenance to citizens and
residents in mortal danger, such as
- the indigent
- dependent persons with no guardian
- Prevent torture
- Protect species and ecosystems
1.6. Powers of the State
The powers of the state necessary for carrying
out its duties are to
- Tax - a taking of property by a
state from a class of its subjects according to rule ordained in a duly
enacted law.
- Establish a currency as legal tender
for public debts
- Collect rent for use of unpossessable
resources
- Tax resource consumption and
pollution
- Rent resource access to the highest
bidders
- Tax consumption, income, or trade
- Take or regulate private property for fair
compensation, to help to
- Regulate natural monopolies
- Prevent anti-competitive artificial
monopolies
- Prevent threats to public safety such
as epidemic, flood, pestilence, and weapons of mass destruction
- Protect species and ecosystems
- Establish police and regulatory services to
prevent domestic aggression
- Establish a military to minimize, reverse,
and punish foreign aggression
- Establish a judiciary to try cases of fact
and law
- Regulate the definition of personhood for
elections, citizenship, adulthood, marriage, incorporation
- Manage spaces annexed or donated to the
state
1.7. Restrictions on
the State
In no case may the state
- Commit torture
- Restrict any person's non-coercive
expression or belief
- Establish or endorse any religion
- Treat persons inequitably on the basis of
ethnicity, sex, age, or belief
- Deny any person equal representation
- Compel labor, except through wartime
military conscription
- Take property without fair compensation
- Confiscate or tax wealth or inheritance, as
opposed to the change in wealth through consumption, income, or trade
- Search or seize persons or property without
a warrant of probable cause
- Compel self-incrimination
- Annex a space without the consent of a
supermajority of the persons residing or owning property or accessing
resources there
- Permit the secession of a region if
- a supermajority in the region does not
approve, or
- secession threatens the security of the
state, or
- the region would get a free ride from
the state's exercise of its duties.
2. Personal Liberty
2.1. Expression
Ban only defamation.
Unrestricted campaign contributions & spending, but require instant
e-disclosure.